Showing posts with label books vs. movies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label books vs. movies. Show all posts

Friday, June 22, 2018

Book #31: The Crucible by Arthur Miller

Who isn’t intrigued by the idea of witches, secret love affairs, secrets, and lies? Well, maybe not in real life, but they sure are entertaining to watch. The Crucible by Arthur Miller is a play depicting the events of the Salem Witch Trials during the late 1600s. The play was originally a flop when it first premiered, but later became one of Miller’s most well known plays. I first read The Crucible when I was in 10th grade; it was part of our American literature curriculum. I remember enjoying the play as a student and was extra enthralled in English class while we read it. Not that I wasn’t extra enthralled the rest of the time.


Why is He So Dirty?: Teaching The Crucible in the Modern Age
            This year, I taught The Crucible to my one class of juniors. I was so excited to teach this play! I had so many ideas of what I wanted to do with it and what I wanted to discuss with my students. Did my students share in my excitement? Absolutely not. This is how it went down:

            Me: Guys, we are going to start reading The Crucible today! It’s about the Salem              Witch Trials! There are witches and drama and people burning at the stake! Isn’t               that exciting?!
             Student 1 slams head down on desk and groans loudly.
             Student 2 stares at me with a “you are crazy” look smacking her gum loudly.
             Student 3 falls asleep sitting up, drool dripping down their face.
 
Thank God for Student 4 who is nodding vigorously and cautiously smiling at me. It is clear that he is only smiling and nodding to make me feel better. The moral of the story here is that it is difficult to get 16 year olds to be excited about literature at 7:30 am. I tried, though.

            With this particular group of students, there was no way they would even read the play if we did not read it aloud. This did not proceed like I imagined it. There were several problems:
            

1. The students would forget which character they were or zone out when it was their turn to read. So whenever it was someone’s turn to read, they prefaced each line with “Oh shit.” Every. Single. Time. I kept yelling “THAT IS NOT IN THE SKRIPT! DO NOT SAY THAT!” Did they ever stop? No.

2. Some students love to be the center of attention and decide that they will read aloud every character that starts with the letter P. If you are familiar with The Crucible, you know that is a decent amount of characters (Parris, Proctor, Putnam). Whenever another student volunteers to read or accidentally read a P role, they will shout “No ‘expletive’ that’s my role!” At least they are excited about something…

3. Sometimes the students realize that the text is actually interesting. However, their reactions while reading are not always appropriate. Exhibit A: "So it’s saying that Abigail was sleeping with Proctor and his is, like, 30?! That’s so gross! He is so old! This b*!&% is cray!”

Image result for the crucible
Look's so dirty, am I right?
As you can see, teaching the play was not what I was expecting with this group of students. I was very entertained while reading this with them. While they are not always the most studious group of teenagers, they did actually begin to enjoy the text about halfway through it. They also liked watching the movie. That’s probably why they put up with reading the book. However, watching the movie presented all sorts of other issues. The students just could not get over why John Proctor looked so dirty. At least three times a day, they commented: “Why won’t he just take a shower?” It didn’t matter that I told them that the play took place in the 1600s and they didn’t have running water back then. They still could not get over that he looked dirty. That was their main take away from The Crucible.

The Witch Hunt
The Crucible was originally written as an allegory for the Red Scare in the 1950s, referring to the McCarthy trials which was a hunt to find communists hiding in plain site. Arthur Miller was called to the stand during these trials and asked to name people he thought were communists. Miller refused to do so despite what it might do to his reputation. This mirrors Proctor’s predicament in The Crucible. His wife is first accused of being a witch and when Proctor begins to ask questions about the accuser, he is then accused. The only way for Proctor to not be hanged as a witch is to admit to being a witch even though it would be a lie. His only options are to lie and say he is a witch so he can live or to tell the truth and die. Is it better to survive or to die morally? It’s a tough question. Human being are born with the instinct for survival yet we have a moral compass. What happens when these two things are at odds?
            This idea of a witch hunt is applicable to many situations. My students could relate to this because they all deal with rumors and gossips. It is so easy for someone to say something that is untrue and for that rumor to spread and transform over time. False accusations are very common when it is a he said/she said type situation. I can not tell you how many times my juniors would randomly should out "THIS IS HOW LIKE THAT ONE TIME MY EX..." My response was always "I DON'T WANT TO KNOW!" because, trust me, sometimes we are just better off not knowing what they do in their free time. 


In your face, Abigail!

Other Thoughts
- Lorelai mentions The Crucible (probably the movie version) to Luke when she says “Not gonna talk about how good you’d look dressed as one of the guys from The Crucible.” She obviously doesn’t have the same problem as my students.
- Liam Neeson played John Proctor in the 2002 Broadway revival of the play and we all know how we feel about Liam Neeson. I would watch that man in anything.
- I didn’t talk much about Abigail and the girls in this post, but I just have to say that this play shows how teenage girls can be the worst. I have been one. I deal with them everyday. I know. Sometimes they can be the sweetest, but also they can be very scary. The Crucible shows this first hand.

Pictures
- Book Cover: https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=images&cd=&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=2ahUKEwiX7_HRhujbAhVPzlkKHUEACV0QjRx6BAgBEAU&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.goodreads.com%2Fbook%2Fshow%2F17250.The_Crucible&psig=AOvVaw3InrROTXmMiEUEdfWU7rdS&ust=1529783712041474
- Proctor: http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/0df639c8d68299560f3d2ce9e90b0556.jpg- Meme:http://imoviequotes.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/1-the-crucible-quotes.gif

Sunday, November 12, 2017

Bonus Books: George Sand, Mark Twain, Schindler's List, and Plato


There are many authors referenced throughout Gilmore Girls that are not on the official list. Lorelai and Rory rattle off book and movie titles without skipping a beat. References can fly by even the most attentive viewer. I have a friend who would pause the show and look up a reference when he didn't know it. Personally, I only cared about the literature references. Being the book nerd I am, I have started to add these author onto my reading pile. It’s not as if I need to add more to the 339 book list, but, hey, I am a perfectionist.

George Sand
George Sand was referenced in episode two during the exchange between Paris and the teacher when War and Peace, Anna Karenina, and all the Dickens passages were mentioned. The teacher says that “Dostoevski’s main authorial influences…” and Paris responds with “George Sand and Balzac.” Books by Dostoevski and Balzac appear later on the list, but George Sand does not. George Sand is one of those names I have come across in my literature studies, but never made the effort to look up. It turns out that George Sand is a French FEMALE novelist from the 1800s. She was born Amantine Lucile Aurore Dupin, but chose George Sand as her pseudonym. Obviously, more people would read her work if they thought it was written by a man in that time period.
            I found one of her short stories, “The Devil’s Pool” online. It is a pastoral novella which has a heavy focus on nature and human relationships. It follows a young widower as he travels to meet a potential new wife. However, he ends up falling for the young woman who is traveling with him to watch over his children. Sweet, right? No. He is 28 and she is 15…and she doesn’t really want to marry him. But he persuades her that she should and she says yes. How romantic? Am I right?
            It isn’t a very complex story and much of the narrative is focused on the day to day life of the French country side. If you recall, Dickens and Tolstoy spent much of their novels focusing on the day to day life of different social groups in their novels. While I see the importance of recording the everyday life of the people, it can get a bit boring to read. 

Mark Twain 
            Mark Twain is one of my favorite nineteenth century American authors. If you remember, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is one of my favorite classic novels. Twain is probably best known for his humor and that is how Rory mentions him while golfing with her grandfather. Twain is noted for saying “Golf is a good walk spoiled.” I couldn’t have said it better myself! Golf is boring and the only entertaining way to play it is through Putt-Putt at the beach.
            Since no specific title by Twain was referenced here, I chose to read The Prince and the
Pauper, a text I always wanted to read, but never had the chance. I am sure you all know the basic plot of the story: two boys, a prince and a pauper, who realize they look exactly alike switch places and trouble ensues. Variations of this story have been told again and again through films like The Parent Trap and Mary-Kate and Ashley’s It Takes Two. I’m also pretty sure there is a Mickey Mouse version of the tale as well as a Barbie version. 
            This tale is so enticing because every person always wonders what their life could be like if they had taken different opportunities or were placed in different circumstances. More so, the idea of the double, or doppelganger, is a motif that stretches across time. There is an innate fear of our “evil twin” or our dark side. Even though Twain does not make the prince nor the pauper evil, that fear of the double is still present. What if someone can’t tell you apart? Can your identity be taken? These fears are at the root of many stories on television today (The Vampire Diaries, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Alias, Charmed, Supernatural).
            I enjoyed reading The Prince and the Pauper, but not as much as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn. Even though I liked the idea of the story, the writing did not draw me in as much as some of Twain’s other stories. Maybe it was the point in time that I read it, but I could not seem to really get invested in the book or the characters. That doesn’t mean that the book is not worth reading. It just means that I couldn’t connect to the story at the point in my life that I read it.

Schindler’s List by Thomas Keneally

            Schindler’s List, the movie, was referenced in episode two when Rory mentioned that she had been part of the German club at Stars Hollow High. If my high school had a German club, I probably would have joined it purely because I have family there (not because I can speak German).
            It is common knowledge among book lovers that you must, you absolutely must, claim Schindler’s List by Thomas Keneally is one of those instances. Maybe it is because I have a thing for Liam Neeson…
that the book is better than the movie. 99% of the time I adhere to this and it is usually true. I can only think of a handful of times when the movie is better than the book.
            All joking aside, the story of Schindler’s List is very intense and emotional both in book and movie form. However, seeing it on screen helps you visualize the horrors of the Holocaust. The black and white visuals make the story even more intense than it already is and made the story more engaging. Keneally’s writing style was not very engaging. The plot was there, but the narrative in which it was told was not. It is definitely an example of how a writer’s voice and style are essential to a story. A story can be exciting and moving, but if it isn’t told in the correct manner, it is not going to be as impactful to an audience. In the case of Schindler’s List, the movie tells the story better than the novel.

Plato
            Since Plato was name dropped in episode three, I decided to read Plato’s short piece “Crito” found in my trusty old AP Language 40 Essays Anthology. “Crito” is a dialogue between Socrates and his old friend Crito in which Crito tries to persuade Socrates to escape from prison. Socrates explains to Crito in this dialogue that he has accepted the results of his trial, which is
death. The entire exchange is propelled by questions, aka the Socratic method. Plato, who was a student of Socrates, wanted to showcase this method of reasoning. The Socratic method focuses on teaching through questioning. As a teacher myself, I see myself using this daily. Rather than just giving students facts or telling students what to think, I use higher order questions (There are three levels of questioning. I won’t bore you with them). We want to give students the tools for self-discovery and come to conclusions for themselves. Teachers are supposed to guide the discovery process and questioning is one of the ways to do so. Although I don’t agree with Socrates in this passage (I say, he should have saved himself), I understand his teaching process and what Plato was supposed to show in this passage.

            My sister has been taking a philosophy course this semester in college. She tells me about some of the passages she has had to read and I proofread her papers. Anything she has to say on the topic of Plato is probably ten times more interesting than what I just said.


Pictures
George Sand: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/5/54/George_Sand_by_Nadar%2C_1864.jpg/1200px-George_Sand_by_Nadar%2C_1864.jpg
The Prince and the Pauper:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/b/bb/Disney%27s_The_Prince_and_the_Pauper_%281990%29.jpg
Schindler's List
https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/914HFOPuVwL.jpg
Plato:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/d/da/Plato_Pio-Clemetino_Inv305.jpg/220px-Plato_Pio-Clemetino_Inv305.jpg

Sunday, June 18, 2017

Book #15: The Shining by Stephen King

I know I said that the next book would be War and Peace, but it has taken me awhile to get through it. This is partially because I’ve been reading other books while reading it (I know! I should just suck it up and power through!). I read a chapter of War and Peace, I read a chapter of something else, and so on. So I decided to continue the challenge as I read this huge monster of a book, especially because the next book on the list was Stephen King’s The Shining (a fun The Shining. I have seen countless of other classic horror films, but never got around to seeing this one. You know, based on this blog, you probably think I haven’t read or seen much of anything…I promise you that I have!
read!). Anybody who claims to be one of my friends knows that I love a good scary story. Horror movies, in particular, are my favorite. It may come to a shock to you, then, that I have never seen the movie version of
            I first read The Shining about ten years ago when I was a sophomore year in high school. Geez, I am old. Wow. Because it had been so long, I decided to reread it. I remember reading it the first time and not being blown away. I wasn’t sure if this was because I was too young to appreciate, didn’t quite understand it, or just wasn’t a fan. Before reading it this time, I finally sat down and watched the movie. I enjoyed the movie, but it is one that I only need to watch every ten years or so. I can understand why it is a classic and why it is a Gilmore favorite. It is actually the movie of The Shining that Lorelai mentions when she is on the phone with her mother talking about installing a DSL line (oh, the days before wifi). However, because it was a book first, of course, it is on the list. This brings me to my first topic:

Book vs. Movie
            Whenever it comes down to the book vs. movie debate, I usually side with the book. 99.9% of the time, the book is better than the movie or television adaptation. There is a very short list of movies that are better than their source of adaptation. That list, in my eyes, is Bridget Jones’s Diary, Twilight (because you can visually see the abs), and Harry Potter. I’m sure there are a few more, but I’ll let you know as I think of them.
            In this situation, I do think that the novel The Shining is better than the movie The Shining. Watching the movie and reading the novel in such quick succession made me more certain in
my opinion. Both are enjoyable, but there are major differences which helped me make my decision. For one, the main character Jack is presented in very different lights. In the movie, it is made clear from very early on that something is wrong with Jack. The movie presents this as something that is inherently within Jack before the story starts and that the evil that manifests in the character was present there all along. In the novel, King presents Jack as a flawed human character. He is not evil when the story begins, but is a man struggling with alcoholism, losing his job, and the tension in his marriage. He is not perfect by any means, but he is NOT an inherently evil man. King makes it abundantly clear that Jack loves his wife, Wendy, and his son, Danny. The movie makes Jack extremely unlikeable from very early on making it hard to sympathize with him and, therefore, not making us feel any sympathy for Jack as he loses himself. The novel makes Jack's inner turmoil evident to the reader. We learn about how his father abused him and why he succumbed to alcohol. We see how the voices of the ghosts of the hotel slowly take over Jack’s mind so that he eventually gives his soul up to the hotel. The movie makes it clear that Jack is the bad guy while the novel presents the hotel as the bad guy.
            This difference is one of the reasons why Stephen King dislikes the critically acclaimed
movie adaptation of his work. King is not shy about voicing his ideas and opinions to the world. This is something we see to this day as he was recently blocked by Donald Trump on Twitter. I can only imagine how difficult it is for an author to give up authority of their work. If I ever write a book (and mark my words, I will write a book!) and it is turned into either a movie or TV series, I’d want to be intimately involved in the process.

The Uncanny
Freud coined the term the “uncanny” which refers to something that is familiar, but slightly off. It is unsettling because it is so close to something we know yet there is part of it that does not fit our normal schema for the world. This is my paraphrase of what the uncanny means and it explains why scary stories are so popular, specifically Stephen King’s stories. If you look at most of King’s works, what makes them the most unsettling is that the horror comes from something that connects to our human world. Sure, he includes ghosts, vampires, aliens, etc. but these are all rooted in something that connects to human nature. What is scary about The Shining isn’t just that it is about a haunted hotel, but it is that it takes a normal man and takes him to the edge of madness. We know that ghosts are not real (debatable), but losing your mind is. What scares us is not the supernatural, but what the supernatural represents. Although, the cheap scares in slasher movies can be a bit scary for some of us.

Random Thoughts
- I once tried to trick a guy into watching a scary movie with me. This did not end well as he opened the door, saw the television scream, and yelled “HELL NO” as he slammed the door. I had to earn my forgiveness by giving him all the Kit-Kats in my Halloween candy mix.

- The most haunted room in the Overlook Hotel is room 217. My classroom is 217. Coincidence? I think not. I always joked that my classroom was haunted because the TV would randomly turn on and things would fall off the walls. Now it makes a lot more sense.

- King takes inspiration for The Shining from his own struggle with alcoholism and parenting. It is often said that you write what you know. This makes sense, but writing what you know tends to get you in trouble sometimes. I’ve been there.

- One of my favorite author feuds is between Stephen King and James Patterson. Personally, I like both authors for different reasons. However, it is extremely interesting to read about. I think it should be the next season of that FX show about Feuds.

- Colorado is the setting of this novel so I have to ask: Why is Colorado so popular? At least two of my good friends have moved out there and several other people I know have done so as well. Of all the places I would move to, Colorado would not be first on the list.

- Since this book is about a psychic boy, I would like to share that my mother believes that certain members of our family are slightly psychic. But, she likes to point out that I did not inherit this gift.


- The Shining has a sequel: Dr. Sleep. It is about a grown up Danny. I wonder how it compares to The Shining. I’ll let you know.


Pictures
Movie Poster:http://static.rogerebert.com/uploads/movie/movie_poster/the-shining-1980/large_zc5y5OwKSV9MDXpfWxwrOjyRHsq.jpg
Book Cover:http://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1309974274i/231786._UY200_.jpg
Movie Still:http://www.heyuguys.com/images/2014/08/The-Shining.jpg
Meme:https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/originals/86/ee/a0/86eea0092015a877a024271bed9a3ced.jpg

Monday, October 10, 2016

Book #3 Rosemary's Baby by Ira Levin

When people meet me, they assume I am the type of girl who loves, loves, LOVES, romantic comedies. Maybe it’s my perpetually happy demeanor or my resting nice face; I’m not completely sure. However, my favorite type of movie is not the romantic comedy. It is the horror movie. This shocks people. They ask “Why would such a sweet, joyous girl like you enjoy scary movies?” (well, they might not phrase it exactly like that). The reason I love horror movies is because I enjoy the adrenaline rush. I always say that it reminds of the feeling of having a crush and your heart beats uncontrollably. People look at me like I’m crazy when I make that comparison. They may be right and I might just have a twisted sense of romance. But think of it this way, it is also the same feeling I have on the top of a roller coaster. All of these situations involve an uncontrollable variable for which it makes the situation exciting and full of suspense.
            I know that was a tangent, but it was necessary to describe my love of scary movies (and stories) in order to express my thoughts on Ira Levin’s novel Rosemary’s Baby.

Tall, Dark, Stranger
            Rory mentions Rosemary’s Baby when she first meets her boyfriend Dean in the halls of Stars Hollow High. He bumps into her and she drops her books. The first thing she says to Dean is “God! You’re like Ruth Gordon just standing there with a tannis root. Make a noise.” Not really the most polite thing to stay to a cute boy who is trying to talk to you. Luckily, Dean knew exactly what Rory was talking about and proved that he could keep up with her. For myself, I definitely find this a plus in a boy. It is difficult to find one who can keep up with me, not just in pop culture references, but one who understands my humor and challenges me intellectually. 
Books vs. Movies
The reference Rory made above was to the movie version of Rosemary’s Baby and not the book. But because I am a big nerd and it was a book first, it was included on the official list. (It also took me awhile to find a copy of this book because someone else had it on hold before me at the library. Rosemary’s Baby, but perhaps I would like it better than the book in this instance.
Grrrr…So I read it on my phone instead). Whenever a book is adapted into a movie, there are always changes made because page and screen are different mediums. Therefore, fans of the book are never going to be one hundred percent pleased. I always abide by the rule that the book is better because it is the original source, but that is subject to debate. I have never seen the movie version of

What is horror?
            The reason I did not particularly enjoy Rosemary’s Baby is because it was not scary nor was it suspenseful and it did not live up to the hype. On the cover of the novel, it reads “The Masterpiece of
Modern Horror.” With a subtitle like that, you can’t help but think the book is going to be scary. Maybe it was because it was written in 1967 or I’ve seen too many horror movies and I am desensitized to scary stories. I do not think it is the second and I do not believe it is the first either, as Edgar Allen Poe stories scare me and they are much older. Perhaps, if I had had a child, I would find this story scarier. The idea of an evil fetus growing inside of you is creepy, but this idea was not made present till the end of the novel. In my opinion, I thought the build up was too slow and the characters were frustrating. Rosemary was very one dimensional and was kind of bland. I could not find a connection with her and therefore did not sympathize with her struggles. She relied on her husband and other characters too much and did not trust herself when she needed to. If Rosemary trusted her instincts in the beginning of the novel rather than other peoples' words, the entire conflict could have been avoided (but there would be no book then). 
Good versus Evil
            If you have not read the ending or seen the ending of the movie, I suggest you do not read this next part if you do not want to be spoiled. Although I did not think this novel was scary, I do hold an appreciation for the ending. The beauty of the ending is in the simplicity of the writing. Rosemary’s baby is revealed to be the son of Satan and Rosemary is torn between loving her child and running away from evil. In the end, Rosemary chooses to stay with her baby but it is unclear if she is going to raise the child to be good or if she is going to succumb to the dark side. Levin leaves it purposefully ambiguous with this ending which frustrates some readers and pleases others. I enjoy ambiguous endings because it leaves room for interpretation and keeps you wondering. You are more likely to think about a story if part of it is left open-ended. Why else do you think this trend of television reboots and revivals are so popular?


Rosemary’s Baby, although, not my favorite read, was an essential one. As a horror buff, it is one that I needed to continue my education on the genre. It is also one of the novels/movies that the Gilmore girls reference several times throughout the series so therefore it was an important one. One of the lessons I have learned in my life, is that a story does not have to be your favorite in order to learn from it.

***The next book, The Second Sex by Simone de Beauvoir, is really long so the next post might take longer than others.


Citations
Book cover:https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/originals/b3/64/36/b364362c81418d379a7b344e4d7e9835.jpg
Movie Still:http://az795576.vo.msecnd.net/bh-uploads/2015/12/rosemarys-baby-still-1050x700.jpg